I Care A Lot Review: Compromised But Hugely Entertaining

There is so much more that this massively entertaining thriller, I Care A Lot, could have given us. What remains is nonetheless quite something.

4258 Reads |  

I Care A Lot Review: Compromised But Hugely Entertaining


The first half of this insanely wicked stroll down  Greed Street is so frigging entertaining, I  was hooked, lined and sinkered…whatever that means!  Welcome to the world of pure-white red-hot avarice. There in that razor-sharp haircut is Marla Grayson, played by one of the most accomplished contemporary American actresses Rosemund Pike.

What does Marla do? Well, she is a professional certifiable  scamster. Along with her business and life partner Fran (Eiza González) Marla siphons off the property and wealth of the elderly, declares them unfit for unassisted living, has them locked away at an old-age facility. It is the kind of horrific subterfuge I’d expect in a  third-world country:   unscrupulous, unfettered by any intervention of guilt or conscience. Marla has as her accomplice the entire administration from doctors and nurses to lawyers and judges.

But then Marla does what all over-smart crooks do. She over-reaches. She pulls her scam on Jennifer Peterson (Diane Wiest) whose son Roman Lunyov (Peter Dinklale) turns out to be a Russin mobster. So far this film is a sparkling illustration of perfect writing direction and performances.


There is an exceptional sequence in Marla’s office where a lawyer (brilliantly played by  Chris Messina) tries to bribe  Marla out of the crisis that she has got herself into free Jennifer Peterson and walk away with a hefty sum of money. The lawyer offers coolly.

Marla refuses the offer. This is where the screenplay begins to flounder. The screenplay grows as outlandish as  Marla’s cocky scamming. The cat-and-mouse game between Marla and  Roman is just not convincing or even amusing. And that remarkably stupid judge in the courtroom who repeatedly keeps falling into Marla’s hands belongs in a sitcom on legal drop-outs.

It just grows exponentially absurd and violent until we reach the utterly preposterous climax which seems to have been written with almost suicidal absurdity. Have I seen a more entertaining first-half seriously damaged by a  severely compromised second-half? No, I haven’t. Is the film still worth your while? Yes, it is. There is so much going for it. Rosemund Pike’s brazenly immortal character and the actress’ complete belief in her character’s immortality.

And Diane Wiest makes a formidable adversary. I wish there were more confrontational scenes between these two brilliant actresses. There is so much more that this massively entertaining thriller could have given us. What remains is nonetheless quite something.

Directed by J Blakeson, I Care A Lot gets 3 and a half stars. 




Image Source: Instagram/netflixicarealot ,youtube/netflix
They say the best things in life are free! India’s favourite music channels 9XM, 9X Jalwa, 9X Jhakaas & 9X Tashan are available Free-To-Air.  Make a request for these channels from your Cable, DTH or HITS operator.