Did Kangana Ranaut DOWNSIZE The Collections Of Simran?

Postmortems are common and the fate of Simran at the ticket windows is going to be no exception. SpotboyE.com analyses what went right and wrong for Simran

18193 Reads |  

Did Kangana Ranaut DOWNSIZE The Collections Of Simran?

The headlines she generated in the past few days had little to do with Simran and a lot to do with her own complicated romantic past. Did Kangana Ranaut do a disservice of sorts to T-Series, who reportedly put Rs 35 crore in the film? Would it not have been prudent to talk about the film in her publicity campaigns rather than 'only' brood about her broken relationships and accuse her ex-flames on various counts?

Or did the Hrithik Roshan-Adhyayan Suman-Hrithik Roshan juicy talk really pay dividends since it made people realise that Simran was round the corner? But then, why only Rs 12.06 crore over four days?

kanagana and hrithik
Kangana Ranaut And Hrithik Roshan In Krrish 3

Yes, that's barely the collection of the first 3 days of Simran.

So, this would be a never-ending debate---- but the point to be made here is that the film also let Kangana down. Most film critics didn't find anything worth praising except Kangana's performance. In fact, Kangana's ex Aditya Pancholi who has been at a big war with her recently even could not help appreciating her histrionics.

Hence, let's find out from distributors and exhibitors what they feel about this hypothesis. Was Kangana right in shifting her focus on her past affairs or not?

Did her marketing strategy on the film (if one may call that) work?

Exhibitor Akshay Rathi says, "I strongly feel that Kangana did a big disservice to the producers of Simran. She went out to promote the film and spoke everything but the film. What sense does that make in today's times when people come to the theatres to watch content and you don't send out messages about your content?"

 aditya and zarina
Aditya And Zarina Exit The Theatre After Watching Simran

However Amod Mehra points out that, irrespective of her loud and brazen quotes on Hrithik-Adhyayan-Suman, Simran has already been sold to Amazon and T-series has recovered 75 per cent of their inventory.

"On the contrary, I think that Kangana's methods to publicise the film by talking about her personal life helped the film. There is a big section in the audiences which compromises of ladies. They loved whatever she spoke in the media prior to the film and they are going out in groups to see the product now. And I know for a fact that most women who have seenSimrant have showered only praises on it."

But Rathi disagrees with Mehra. He says, "Look, I don't think Amazon has given T-Series 75 per cent of their inventory. While a good amount may have come in, it is yet to be ascertained where Simran ends up in terms of life time earnings, At the moment, it doesn't look a big hit for sure. At best, Rs 20 crore in totality. Does that speak really very high about a film whose making including P & A is almost double of that?"

simran poster
Simran Poster

Ravi of PVR Juhu opines, "Why only Simran? We are not doing well with Lucknow Central either, this week. Frankly, we had no hope from these two films, so we are not taken aback or disappointed. As for the exact numbers of Simran at my end, I registered 22 per cent occupancy over the weekend- and that is certainly not great."

"If you are also going to ask me whether Kangana's personal life publicity misfired, I would again say that it hardly mattered to us. We were never looking at Simran as a revenue model," Ravi adds.

What do you think? Did Ms Ranaut downsize Simran? Tell us in the "Comments' section below


Image Source: Manav Manglani 

They say the best things in life are free! India’s favourite music channels 9XM, 9X Jalwa, 9X Jhakaas & 9X Tashan are available Free-To-Air.  Make a request for these channels from your Cable, DTH or HITS operator.