Shilpa Rao On Indian Idol 12 Controversy: 'On Shows Like These, There Should Be A Guru-Shishya Rapport'

Shilpa Rao has weighed in on the issue, saying the contestants should not be targeted with harsh reviews

17878 Reads |  

Shilpa Rao On Indian Idol 12 Controversy: 'On Shows Like These, There Should Be A Guru-Shishya Rapport'
Indian Idol 12, when it aired, got caught up in a few controversies - one of which was the judges playing cheerleaders to the participants. The issue was spoken about on a much larger scale when the late Kishore Kumar’s son, Amit Kumar graced the show. There were reports stating that Amit was asked by the makers to only praise the contestants. Amit Kumar then said he was disappointed by the Kishore Kumar special episode, but was asked to only give positive comments.

Following this, several noted singers weighed in on the debate. Singer Shilpa Rao has now opened up on this issue. She said that the contestants should not be targeted with harsh reviews. "There's a way. It's a 2-way street. You can't look at this from only one side. In addition to this, one should understand that on shows like Indian Idol there should be guru-shishya rapport. Thus, making the participant, means shishya, understand the inputs given by the judges means guru, should be taken in a constructive manner," she told Etimes.

She added, “But as I said there's a way. The way is to tell the participant in such a way that it does not deter his/her progress, it should not hurt him/her. The contestants have to be told in a manner that drives home the message that there is room for improvement. A judge's analysis (on the contestant's performance) can become Prasad.”


Shilpa also said she would abide by the suggestions if she ever judges a show. “For that, a camaraderie needs to develop between the contestants and the judges. I would like to see the judges sitting with the contestants (BTS, she means) where the contestants are not singing or rehearsing or with their make-up on." ALSO READ: Indian Idol 12 Host Aditya Narayan On Amit Kumar's Criticism Of Kishore Kumar Special Episode; 'We Are Not Competing With Kishore Kumar, We Are Celebrating Him'

"Besides building this rapport, as a judge one should know about the mental makeup of the contestants, what are their goals, are they willing to learn when they are on the show and escalate their passion for singing? Or just to achieve quick and short term success," she signed off.

Notably, While Pawandeep Rajan won Indian Idol 12, Arunita Kanjilal emerged as the first runner up. ALSO READ: Shilpa Rao Shares Being Constantly Told Of Having A Different Voice, Hinting At Two Possibilities



Image Source: Instagram/shilparao